Cowgirl Boots, Anxious Nights: Transgender Youth and Families Fight Hostile Legislation and Sky-High Suicide Rates


Households of transgender youth share how they’re constructing secure and affirming properties for his or her youngsters throughout the U.S. amidst such boundaries.

A lady holds the Transgender Pleasure flag throughout a march on July 9, 2022. A 2020 examine within the Journal of Interpersonal Violence confirmed that youth who bought gender-affirming care, corresponding to puberty blockers or hormones, had 60 % decrease odds of despair and 73 % decrease odds of suicidality by the tip of the yr, in contrast with those that weren’t capable of entry such care. (Luis Soto / SOPA Photographs / LightRocket by way of Getty Photographs)

This story was initially printed by MindSite Information.

It began with a pair of cowgirl boots, pink and blue with floral embroidery. Grandpa B. provided to take his grandchild Marty looking for boots. On the retailer, which sells Texas-style western put on, 5-year-old Marty checked out the choices and determined that the best by far was that particular pair from the women’ part. Assigned male at beginning, Marty (a pseudonym) had already been experimenting with mixing “boy” and “lady” garments, some extent of stress between the generations within the household. Grandpa B. wasn’t about to purchase girly pink boots for the child he thought of his grandson. He stated no.

From there, stress grew steadily between Grandpa B. and Marty’s solely dwelling father or mother, whom we’ll name Leslie and who identifies as agender. The household lives in small-town central Texas, and though a lot of their neighbors establish as conservative, Leslie stories that the majority have gracefully accepted Marty’s alternative of pronouns. One neighbor had assumed Marty used male pronouns however requested Leslie after seeing Marty in a gown. Leslie defined that Marty prefers “they/them.”

However Grandpa B. wasn’t so accepting. Even earlier than the journey to get boots, he had begun questioning Marty’s vogue selections. “We’ve observed him with nail polish, glowing ladies’ tights and many others. We really feel that this may very well be complicated him,” Grandpa B. wrote to Leslie in an electronic mail.

A couple of days after the cowgirl boots fiasco—on the identical February day that Texas Gov. Greg Abbot (R) launched an order directing the Texas Division of Household and Protecting Providers (DFPS) to investigate families pursuing “abusive gender-transitioning procedures”—there was one other improvement. Grandpa B. known as the general public faculty the place Marty attended pre-Ok to falsely report that Marty was being bullied due to clothes. The vice principal declined to debate the problem with Grandpa B. as a result of he wasn’t on the permitted contacts listing and reported the decision to Leslie. A month later, Leslie discovered, Grandpa B. known as the college once more, reported extra bullying, and threatened to name Little one Protecting Providers to report the household for abuse—a risk that by no means materialized.

Marty is even youthful than the 30,000 13-to-17-year-old transgender youth who dwell in Texas, and the 300,000 who dwell throughout the nation that makes up about 1.4 % of all youth, in keeping with the Williams Institute at the UCLA School of Law. Texas has the third largest inhabitants of transgender folks (behind California and New York).

Fourteen payments in 10 states are presently into account that concentrate on transgender folks—addressing medical care, sports activities participation and gender identification documentation. 5 would limit medical take care of minors.

Such care consists of medical remedies like hormones or hormone blockers that suppress the event of bodily traits that battle with an individual’s gender identification, in addition to nonmedical procedures like voice coaching and hair elimination. It could additionally embrace transition surgical procedure, which isn’t beneficial for these below 18 in keeping with present pointers printed by the World Skilled Affiliation for Transgender Well being.

Younger folks’s entry to gender-affirming medical care has develop into a simmering culture-war debate; denying or delaying it seems to be a key consider rising charges of suicide, despair and different psychological well being struggles amongst transgender folks.

Off-the-Charts Suicide Charges

A 2020 examine within the Journal of Interpersonal Violence discovered that 82 percent of transgender people have thought of killing themselves throughout their lifetime, and 40 % have tried suicide, with the very best charges amongst youth. Trans and nonbinary youth even have greater charges of self-harm and expertise extra bullying and despair.

Conversely, youth who bought gender-affirming care—on this case, puberty blockers or hormones—had 60 % decrease odds of despair and 73 % decrease odds of suicidality by the tip of the yr, in contrast with those that weren’t capable of entry such care, in keeping with one other current examine.

“Having an applicable puberty is a big a part of what permits trans folks to dwell a life that cis of us get to take as a right,” stated the examine’s co-author Arin Collin, a trans girl and medical resident on the College of Washington Faculty of Medication.

Marty was born to Leslie and their husband, who died in 2019. Even earlier than Marty might discuss, they might have outbursts and hit their genitals. At a later, verbal stage, Marty would ask Leslie after they would get a vagina or “boobs.” When Marty was 2-1/2, Leslie sought out assist from a toddler psychiatrist as a result of Marty was so distressed. The psychiatrist inspired Leslie to let Marty select what they wished to put on, to specific and establish themselves as they wished and to play with no matter “boy” or “lady” toys they wished.

The strategy appeared to work. After Leslie began parenting in a gender-neutral method, Marty stopped attempting to hurt their physique. At a Christmas gathering final yr, Leslie introduced to the prolonged household that Marty identifies as gender-fluid. When Marty’s puzzled grandparents requested what that meant, Marty stated, “Properly, I really feel boy however I additionally really feel lady, and in between, and nothing.”

The one notable pushback in school got here from a lady in Marty’s class who proclaimed that Marty is a boy and thus can’t play with ladies. Leslie labored to assist Marty put together for such interactions, encouraging Marty to be pals with “whoever is pleasant.” When Marty desires to put on a very dramatic outfit, Leslie poses the query: “What is going to you say if somebody says, ‘Boys can’t put on that?’” The reply they’ve settled on: “Individuals get to decide on what they put on.”

When Grandpa B. expressed concern over Marty’s vogue selections, Leslie provided explanations about gender expression, gender identification, sexuality and organic intercourse, an strategy that had labored with their very own father, who’d been involved about Marty sporting a gown for Halloween.

I really feel boy however I additionally really feel lady, and in between, and nothing.


“Marty,” of their Halloween gown in a photograph supplied by the household.

But it surely didn’t work with Grandpa B.

“I don’t have to learn an article to inform me {that a} child with a penis is a boy,” he wrote Leslie in an electronic mail. Ultimately, Leslie reduce communications and blocked him on-line. At one level, Grandpa B. known as the police, who got here to Leslie’s door to do a wellness examine. To Leslie, Grandpa B. had by no means supported gender-neutral parenting, and Abbott’s directive gave him ammunition to contain the authorities.

Abbott’s directive was based mostly on an opinion from Texas Legal professional Common Ken Paxton that hormonal treatments for youth constitute child abuse under Texas law. The directive claims that remedies that “induce transient or everlasting infertility” deprive youngsters of their constitutional proper to procreate. Later, a state-court decide dominated that DFPS is not under any responsibility to investigate child abuse allegations below the Texas Structure.

Path to Higher Psychological Well being

Prior to now decade, rising acceptance of transgender identities has allowed extra transgender youngsters to emerge and transition socially. In 2015, Kristina Olson, a professor at Princeton College, launched the primary set of longitudinal studies of transgender children in the United States, following about 300 youngsters to check their improvement. Amongst her findings is that youngsters who socially transition earlier than puberty and whose identities are supported of their households are as wholesome mentally as their friends who will not be transgender.

Children who socially transition early and have household help could observe paths which might be essentially completely different from transgender generations who got here earlier than them—if youngsters can entry hormone blockers simply previous to the onset of puberty, they will keep away from going by way of the puberty of a gender they don’t establish with and finally keep away from procedures and surgical procedures corresponding to facial feminization surgical procedure or electrolysis to take away undesirable facial hair.

Going by way of puberty of a intercourse they don’t establish with will be traumatic for trans youth who discover their our bodies taking kinds which might be antithetical to how they really feel inside—an element that will contribute to greater charges of despair, nervousness, self-harm and suicide.

Skilled societies together with the American Psychological Association oppose bans on gender-affirming take care of youth, citing research that affirm the psychological advantages of such care and the danger of instantly stopping it on account of restrictive laws.

Olivia is a 32-year-old transgender girl who wasn’t supported by her household as a toddler and didn’t have entry to gender-affirming healthcare. Her childhood recollections revolve across the concern and isolation she felt about her identification, like when she was punished for sporting her mom’s sneakers or demonstrating femme behaviors.

“I primarily had my childhood taken from me,” stated Olivia, who requested to be recognized by her first title solely. Now she desires to inform her story, she added, as a result of “I don’t need youngsters to must undergo the quantity of surgical procedures I’ve needed to undergo.”

She’s had surgical procedure on her face and physique to align together with her gender, however stated “there are specific issues I’ll by no means repair.” She nonetheless feels uncomfortable with how her fingers and toes look. Peak also can point out gender and may’t be modified later in life.

I primarily had my childhood taken from me. I don’t need different youngsters to must undergo that.


Withholding medical care from transgender youngsters till they’re 18 is merciless, she stated—forcing somebody transitioning from male to feminine to have their voices deepen, their muscle tissues develop, and their top improve, setting them aside from different ladies.

“I Am a Boy”

Rabbi Daniel Bogard is set that his son gained’t must undergo such experiences. Bogard grew up and got here of age on the Central Reform Congregation in St. Louis, Mo., and 4 years in the past, he and his spouse, Rabbi Karen Kriger Bogard, grew to become a part of the congregation’s non secular management. Collectively, they’ve an 8-year-old son, Alex (a pseudonym).

From an early age, Alex most well-liked his huge brother’s garments, together with his “boy” underwear. At first the dad and mom thought Alex simply regarded as much as him, however one night time, getting tucked in mattress on the age of 4, Alex requested his father when God would “make me over once more as a boy.” The rabbis let Alex reduce his hair shorter and shorter, till lastly, Alex had a full “boy” reduce at age 5. Alex regarded within the mirror and made a happy pronouncement: “I’m a boy.”

The one bullies in my baby’s life work for the Missouri authorities.

Rabbi Daniel Bogard

Inside his household, in school and of their non secular neighborhood, Alex’s gender identification lies “someplace between no huge deal and a celebrated factor,” Bogard stated. Wanting again, he stated, he and his spouse have been gradual to regulate to Alex’s gender identification as a result of it confirmed up so early. However the night time Alex requested about God making him over, Bogard was up all night time with anxieties, principally about hormones and surgical procedures he figured can be part of Alex’s future. As he got here to phrases with what he calls his internalized transphobia, he realized Alex’s care wouldn’t be all that completely different in scale from the care Alex’s sister requires for her ADHD.

What now fuels Bogard’s nervousness is to be elevating a transgender baby in a state the place a flurry of restrictive legislation was proposed earlier this yr. The night time earlier than he testified within the legislature in help of transgender youth, he had panic assaults and vomited.

Though the payments died with out changing into legislation, Bogard is way from assured that Alex can have entry to gender-affirming medical care sooner or later when he’s more likely to want it.

“The one bullies in my baby’s life work for the Missouri authorities,” he stated. If the state acts to restrict these selections, Bogard, whose grandfather constructed the home his household lives in, is perhaps confronted with a choice: to remain or to go away.

Gina Sequeira, a pediatrician who heads the gender clinic at Seattle Kids’s Hospital, has been fielding calls from apprehensive dad and mom contemplating relocating to Washington from states which might be debating restrictive laws. Some expressed concern that their youngsters could also be unable to proceed the gender-affirming care they’re now receiving. Washington may additionally be enticing to a few of them as a result of medical insurance corporations there are required to cover the costs of puberty blockers, which might vary from $8000 to $50,000 a yr.

Matthew Goldenberg, a psychologist on the clinic, stated there’s a historical past of trans folks needing to leap by way of hoops to get the care they want. He’s transgender and remembers listening to from different transgender of us when he was coming of age in regards to the necessities for transitioning.

Matthew Goldenberg, a transgender man and psychologist on the Gender Clinic of Seattle Kids’s Hospital. (Courtesy of Matthew Goldenberg)

“After I was arising, all people knew that you simply needed to current as very mentally properly,” he stated. “When you have been suicidal or depressed, you weren’t supposed to speak about it, as a result of when you did, they wouldn’t provide you with hormones or they wouldn’t provide the surgical procedure.”

Though some suppliers contend that finishing a sure variety of remedy periods or psychological checks will assist predict a teen’s gender trajectory, Goldenberg insists that no knowledge helps that concept. So he tries to construct from what psychologists do perceive about household techniques and efficient parenting.

When households categorical concern that youngsters could later change their minds about present process a gender transition, Goldenberg presents this reply: Kids who speak in confidence to a father or mother about wanting gender-affirming care are inviting them to attach, to actually get to know them. If the younger particular person later decides to not transition, “what they may know is that at that the majority susceptible place, you liked them and affirmed them and supported them as a father or mother.”

Annette is the mom of Phoebe, a 14-year-old transgender lady in Seattle (their names have been modified). Phoebe, a “late bloomer,” was on puberty blockers for a yr and has simply begun a low dose of estrogen to set off feminine puberty. She’s been vocal about her gender identification since she might communicate, giving the household time to arrange.

What they may know is that at that the majority susceptible place, you liked them and affirmed them and supported them as a father or mother.

Matthew Goldenberg

Annette stated her daughter’s puberty to date has been “a lot extra joyful and wholesome” than hers or a few of Phoebe’s friends. “We’re actually grateful that she will get to have this physique and that she truly took these very deliberate steps to get to have this physique.”

The primary night time her daughter took estrogen, Annette stated, one among Phoebe’s pals visited. The three of them made a little bit impromptu ceremony out of it, she stated, cracking foolish jokes about how Phoebe was rising boobs proper earlier than their eyes.

“If solely folks might know that this doesn’t must be some darkish and dreary path,” Annette stated. “You hear all these scary tales that don’t present you the way glad these youngsters are after they really feel good in their very own pores and skin.”

U.S. democracy is at a harmful inflection level—from the demise of abortion rights, to a scarcity of pay fairness and parental depart, to skyrocketing maternal mortality, and assaults on trans well being. Left unchecked, these crises will result in wider gaps in political participation and illustration. For 50 years, Ms. has been forging feminist journalism—reporting, rebelling and truth-telling from the front-lines, championing the Equal Rights Modification, and centering the tales of these most impacted. With all that’s at stake for equality, we’re redoubling our dedication for the subsequent 50 years. In flip, we want your assist, Support Ms. today with a donation—any amount that is meaningful to you. For as little as $5 each month, you’ll obtain the print journal together with our e-newsletters, motion alerts, and invites to Ms. Studios occasions and podcasts. We’re grateful in your loyalty and ferocity.

Up subsequent:


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here