Is the Gender Wage Gap Really Closing?


A brand new report releases statistics that may make us hopeful—however there are elements not mirrored in these numbers.

Followers maintain up an Equal Pay banner in protest of unequal wages for girls soccer gamers throughout a USWNT match between Nigeria and america on June 16, 2021 at Q2 Stadium in Austin. (Robin Alam / Icon Sportswire by way of Getty Photographs)

A new report out Monday from the Pew Analysis Heart in Washington, D.C., appears at a slice of the gender wage hole not often highlighted: younger ladies below 30 working full-time 12 months spherical. The excellent news? The headline says these ladies are “out-earning younger males in a number of U.S. cities.” However as we’ve come to count on, the information isn’t as sunny because it appears if you drill right down to the small print. Seems “a number of” means a mere 16 of 250 U.S. metropolitan areas the place younger ladies truly out-earn males. Girls’s earnings equal these of males in one other six.

However hey, 22 Metropolitan Statistical Areas on par or above males’s earnings is a heck of quite a bit higher than none, which has traditionally been the case. These 22 range from tiny Wenatchee, Washington (inhabitants 118, 252), the place younger ladies outdo their male counterparts by 20 p.c, to the higher New York space (inhabitants 19.2 million) the place ladies greatest males by 2 p.c.

The Census Bureau estimates that the gender earnings hole for full-time, year-round staff ages 15 and older is 82 p.c, however that quantity hides greater disparities by race and ethnicity. So we took a more in-depth have a look at these 22 locations the place younger ladies are on par or above males in yearly earnings. Greater than half (15) are majority white, together with the highest 5. One, City Honolulu, is majority Asian/Pacific. Six are majority-minority, that means white individuals are lower than 50 p.c of the inhabitants, however the majority is constituted of a mixture together with Black, Hispanic, Native, Asian and others.

However that doesn’t imply younger white ladies are precisely taking the lion’s share in the case of closing the hole. Three out of the 4 cities on the backside of the barrel (below 70 p.c of males’s earnings) for younger ladies below 30 are majority white; one is majority-minority. And within the subsequent group of 14 places with the bottom comparative earnings (70-79 p.c of males’s wages), all are majority white.

Black ladies (63.1 p.c of males’s pay nationally) fare higher after they reside in majority Black cities. The 2 with the biggest Black majorities—Jackson, Mississippi and Detroit—posted far above common numbers for younger ladies’s earnings as in comparison with younger males’s (90 and 89 p.c respectively).

Equally, Hispanic/Latina ladies (58.4 p.c of males’s pay nationally) posted decrease than common gaps in pay between youthful ladies and men in cities with the biggest Hispanic/Latino majorities. Younger ladies in Miami are closest to parity at 99 p.c of males’s pay, and in San Antonio they arrive in at 93 p.c. These within the Texas cities of Laredo and El Paso have been at 84 and 88 p.c respectively in comparison with males’s earnings.

It will be simple to conclude that the traits for younger ladies’s earnings imply the gender pay hole shouldn’t be solely narrowing, however will probably be gone in just a few years as they proceed to achieve expertise.

Not so quick. 

The actually large whammy for the younger ladies below 30 studied by Pew goes to hit simply across the nook. Harvard economist Claudia Goldin has discovered that the gender wage hole in America is the biggest for women in their 30s—in different phrases, their prime childbearing years.

The aptly named “motherhood penalty” in wages could be very a lot alive and effectively within the U.S., and it prices ladies round $16,000 per year in comparison with fathers, who pay no penalty in any respect. Actually, fathers are seen as more reliable workers than non-fathers. And even in workplaces that supply parental depart to males in addition to ladies, fathers take much less.

Closing the Gender Pay Hole

So what’s the reply? Primary is fixing our pitiful patchwork of childcare. If the U.S. had extra reasonably priced and obtainable childcare many extra ladies couldn’t solely keep within the workforce when children come alongside, they might take much less day without work when children are sick or colleges shut down.

We may be taught from nations like Iceland and Sweden, which lead the World North in labor drive participation by moms. It’s fairly simple to see why. Usually cited internationally because the gold customary in early studying, Sweden’s Educare is a nationwide community of backed preschools that present childcare and training for the youngsters of all working dad and mom from the age of 1.

Greater than a child-minding service, Educare lecturers and assist workers are effectively educated and actively encourage kids’s studying and growth by a focused nationwide curriculum. And whereas preschools in Sweden usually function between 6:30am and 6:30pm each day, many have now prolonged hours to accommodate shift staff, together with nights and weekends.

Charges are proportional to parental earnings and capped at a month-to-month most. And youngsters from the age of three obtain 525 hours a 12 months freed from cost. The system is complemented by paid parental depart preparations that present 480 days for every youngster, insured at 80 p.c of parental earnings.

Let’s hope the U.S. can match a number of the beneficial properties in different nations earlier than the feminine staff within the Pew examine hit the wall of motherhood and childcare. 

Final fall, the U.S. Home handed the primary national paid family and medical leave bill that would offer 4 weeks of paid household and medical depart beginning in 2024, largely alongside get together traces. We urge younger ladies voters to recollect in November.

If you found this article helpful, please consider supporting our independent reporting and truth-telling for as little as $5 per month.

Up subsequent:


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here