Legacy Admissions Is a Women’s Issue


Harvard graduation ceremonies at Harvard College in Cambridge, Mass, on Could 29, 2014. (Rick Friedman / Corbis by way of Getty Photos)

On Oct. 31, the Supreme Courtroom heard oral arguments about universities’ use of affirmative action, a kind of race-conscious admissions. Nevertheless, sprinkled all through the hours-long hearings have been references to an older and extra arcane admissions coverage referred to as legacy admissions.

Legacy admissions have been first established a century in the past within the Northeast, to limit the matriculation of Jewish and Southern European immigrants into prestigious establishments. They have been designed to guard the positions of white, rich, Protestants at elite universities. Since they perform by rewarding these with a familial connection to a college, legacy admissions proceed to hinder the matriculation of these new to school or to the US—candidates of coloration, low socioeconomic standing and immigrants.

Legacy admissions have been created by males of excessive society and largely served to profit males of an analogous standing. Ladies in contrast had solely lately gained the battle to attend college.

In 1840, Catherine Brewer grew to become the primary girl to graduate with a bachelor’s diploma. It took greater than three decades for the primary girl to earn a legislation diploma. And whereas girls slowly grew to become extra concerned in post-secondary schooling, they have been steadily educated in girls’s schools, the place on the time alternatives have been typically starkly restricted. It wasn’t till 1969 that a number of prestigious girls’s schools lastly merged with their male counterparts or started to in any other case admit girls.

As extra girls started to matriculate into college, they grew to become bigger beneficiaries of legacy admissions. In 2021, girls made up 59.5 percent of all U.S. school college students, a file excessive and stark reversal from 1970, when males comprised 58 percent of undergraduates. Nevertheless, the advantages of legacy admissions have been felt unequally throughout feminine candidates as a complete. A 2019 examine confirmed that at Harvard (one of many universities the place admissions is finest understood) 70 p.c of legacy candidates have been white. Information from Harvard in 2002 confirmed solely 7.6 percent of legacy admits have been from underrepresented teams.

Whereas some take into account the benefit given to legacy candidates as negligible, quite a lot of information point out that it has appreciable affect. A 2007 examine of selective schools indicated that legacy candidates have been thrice extra more likely to be admitted than an equally certified non-legacy applicant. At Harvard, legacy candidates have been six occasions extra more likely to be admitted than non-legacies of equal credentials.

Regardless of the profit that extra feminine college students are deriving from legacy admissions, they’ve additionally been a few of its most vocal critics. Statistically, younger girls lean extra progressive, a pattern which has markedly elevated over the previous decade. In 2011, 30 p.c of girls 18-29 years of age recognized as liberal, whereas in 2021, 44 p.c recognized as such. The proportion of younger males figuring out as liberal throughout the identical time interval remained largely the identical, at round 25 p.c.

Ladies are additionally extra more likely to assist efforts at enhancing variety. A current poll out of Rutgers College revealed that 58 p.c of girls consider that ethnic and racial variety within the office is “crucial,” in comparison with 48 p.c of males. The margin between women and men was even better when requested concerning the significance of gender variety within the office.

It is sensible, then, that feminine college students at among the U.S.’s premier establishments have taken up the mantle to finish legacy admissions. Zoe Fuad, co-president of the group College students for Instructional Fairness, stated she sees legacy admissions as reinforcing a “cycle of inequity” designed to serve white rich males. Over the previous a number of years, she’s labored to push Brown College to disclose data associated to legacy admissions and finally finish the observe altogether.

Different examples of feminine college students spurring their administrations ahead on legacy admissions abound. At each Tufts College and Cornell College, Ameya Menta and Claire Tempelman, respectively, authored resolutions in opposition to legacy admissions that have been adopted by their scholar senates or assemblies. 

As extra universities and state legislatures get rid of legacy admissions, corresponding to AmherstTufts University School of Medicine and the State of Colorado, college students proceed to achieve traction within the battle for instructional fairness.

“As girls, we perceive that the battle for fairness entails dismantling the hidden benefits that result in persistent segregation within the classroom and past,” stated Menta. “Legacy admissions just isn’t a distant coverage for us. Opposing it’s a battle for our personal rights and a battle to say our place as college students and leaders.” 

Up subsequent:

U.S. democracy is at a harmful inflection level—from the demise of abortion rights, to a scarcity of pay fairness and parental depart, to skyrocketing maternal mortality, and assaults on trans well being. Left unchecked, these crises will result in wider gaps in political participation and illustration. For 50 years, Ms. has been forging feminist journalism—reporting, rebelling and truth-telling from the front-lines, championing the Equal Rights Modification, and centering the tales of these most impacted. With all that’s at stake for equality, we’re redoubling our dedication for the subsequent 50 years. In flip, we want your assist, Support Ms. today with a donation—any amount that is meaningful to you. For as little as $5 each month, you’ll obtain the print journal together with our e-newsletters, motion alerts, and invites to Ms. Studios occasions and podcasts. We’re grateful to your loyalty and ferocity.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here