The Tragedy of Child Drownings


On a summer time morning in 2013, Jeffrey Brown dropped off his 6-year-old son, Grant, at a neighborhood summer time camp in Chapel Hill, North Carolina. The household had simply come into city from Cambridge, Massachusetts, to go to associates, and along with every week full of barbecues, a Durham Bulls baseball sport, and different summer time enjoyable, Grant was excited to attend a neighborhood day camp.

A couple of hours later, Brown received the decision.

“They mentioned that Grant was receiving CPR after being discovered within the pool,” Brown says.

However the CPR would come too late, and Grant died quickly afterward.

Brown had been hesitant about “pool time” on the camp as a result of Grant wasn’t a powerful swimmer. He solely agreed after camp administration assured him that an on-duty lifeguard watched the pool always and that youngsters who couldn’t swim have been confined to shallow water.

Video surveillance would later present this to be partly true, says Brown. There was a lifeguard on obligation – a single lifeguard to look at a pool crowded with about 60 youngsters. Counselors tried to assist, however in a pool full of that many youngsters, it was exhausting to maintain up with all the things that was occurring, and Grant discovered his means into deeper water.

And so even with a lifeguard on obligation and counselors and youngsters throughout, the video exhibits Grant desperately arising and down, clearly struggling for air. A camp counselor stands shut by, although turned within the different course, for over 2.5 minutes.

Grant spends one other 3.5 minutes on the backside of the pool earlier than two fellow campers discover him and pull him up.

“I can’t clarify to you the gut-wrenching, ripping agony of getting to let go of your youngster whenever you have been anticipating to see him that afternoon.”

It’s Extra Widespread Than You Suppose

In case you assume that is only a freak accident, says Brown, you’re mistaken.

Drowning is the No. 1 reason behind demise for youngsters 1 to 4 years outdated and the No. 2 reason behind demise for these 5 to 9 years outdated.

Cautious supervision of younger youngsters round water, ideally by licensed lifeguards, is important to maintain youngsters protected, says William D. Ramos, PhD, an aquatics skilled with the American Crimson Cross Scientific Advisory Council.

“When youngsters are close to water, they require a excessive degree of supervision that’s devoted, fixed, and with none distractions,” Ramos says.

Minority youngsters specifically could also be at increased danger in swimming swimming pools. Although drowning deaths have gone down general, racial and ethnic disparities persist. Between 1999 and 2019, American Indian/Alaska Native youngsters drowned at twice the speed of white youngsters.

Between 1999 and 2010, Black American youngsters ages 5 to 19 have been greater than 5 occasions extra more likely to drown in swimming pools. The speed was highest for 11- to 12-year-old Black People, who have been greater than 10 occasions extra more likely to drown than white youngsters the identical age.

However the numbers don’t at all times inform a transparent story. For instance, Asian/Pacific Islander youngsters are considerably much less more likely to drown than whites (and on common) between ages 1 and 4. Then between ages 5 and 19, their odds of drowning go up increased than whites and better than common.

The explanations for these increased charges are complicated and based mostly partially on tradition, says Ramos.

A part of it might be early entry to swimming pools and correct swimming instruction. However it’s additionally generational. If mother and father don’t know how you can swim, then they’re unlikely to show their youngsters, he says.

Why? Social historical past can typically shed some gentle on the topic. Black People specifically have been typically barred from swimming pools within the “white solely” golf equipment and public services that provided protected swimming and swim instruction, based on Victoria Wolcott, PhD, College of Buffalo historical past professor and writer of a e-book on segregated recreation titled Race, Riots, and Curler Coasters. The place Black People did collect to swim, objecting whites have been identified to throw nails, bleach, and even acid into swimming pools, Wolcott says. Within the Forties, there have been race-based riots in massive swimming swimming pools in Los Angeles, St. Louis, Baltimore, and Washington, DC.

So it’s maybe comprehensible that sure American ethnic teams are lower than captivated with heading off to the pool to be taught to swim, says Wolcott.

The Risk Is Greatest at Residence

Virtually 90% of drownings happen in “residence swimming pools.” That may embody your personal pool or that of a member of the family, pal, or neighbor.

It occurs extra typically when there’s no protected barrier like a locked fence round a pool, or when the barrier isn’t working. Youngsters can even escape from the home by unlocked doorways, home windows, and even pet doorways to get to the pool.

Drowning isn’t a “Hollywood occasion,” says Ramos. What he means is that it may possibly occur with out fanfare, with terrifying velocity and in virtually full silence.

“The easiest way to forestall it’s by avoiding any and all unsupervised entry to water.”

Meaning ALL entry – together with inside the house. Yearly, round 90 youngsters drown inside the house, two-thirds of them within the bathtub. It may possibly occur in as little as 2 inches of water.

The tragedy, says Ramos, is that these are all largely preventable deaths.

What You Can Do

With summer time trip shut at hand, mother and father should be additional vigilant, Ramos says. Listed below are some issues you are able to do:

  • At all times supervise your youngsters round water, regardless of how effectively they’ll swim. In case you can’t watch them, make certain there are sufficient accountable adults that may. Keep away from distractions like studying or utilizing your telephone as you watch.
  • In case you’re in open water, like an ocean, lake, or river, you must at all times be in a Coast Guard-approved life jacket. Different merchandise aren’t examined as effectively to make sure an upright place whereas floating on the water. You can too use life jackets on weaker swimmers of any age, at any time when they’re in or round water. Floating toys usually are not security units.
  • Get formal swimming classes for youngsters at as younger an age as doable from a good and authorized teacher. The American Red Cross or your native YMCA are a great place to start out. However keep in mind that your youngsters will nonetheless want “shut and fixed supervision across the water. “We should not rely on our youngsters to save lots of themselves,” says Ramos.
  • Construct a fence to totally enclose your pool with a self-latching gate that separates it from the home. When not in use, take away all toys from the realm that may appeal to youngsters. In case your youngster goes to be at one other residence, ask about protected pool entry. Pool covers are not a protected substitute for a fence, based on the American Academy of Pediatrics. The primary purpose for that is that they require opening and shutting for every use and as soon as open, any youngster may wander into the realm. There are also issues with standing water on high of the duvet and doable entanglement in sure sorts of covers.
  • Be taught CPR. It may possibly save somebody’s life within the time it takes for paramedics to reach. Contact the American Crimson Cross or American Coronary heart Affiliation for coaching programs in your space. Some programs additionally could also be out there on-line.

Keep in mind, drowning can occur anyplace, together with at supervised summer time camps like Grant’s. There are some issues you are able to do to attempt to preserve your youngsters protected.

Begin by looking for out the authorized requirements for water supervision at camps or public swimming pools in your space. These requirements differ extensively by state.

North Carolina, the place Grant attended day camp, doesn’t require a lifeguard or any grownup to look at the physique of water the place youngsters swim. New York and Massachusetts do require water supervision. Different states, like South Carolina, don’t regulate day camps in any respect.

Even when there are laws, they might be too lax or the camp is probably not following them.

In Grant’s case, a single lifeguard was not sufficient for a pool stuffed with 60 youngsters.

“If in any respect doable, take a day to watch the camp earlier than permitting your youngster to attend. And don’t be afraid to ask questions,” Ramos says.

How massive is the pool? What number of youngsters are in it at anyone time? What number of lifeguards are there? How well-trained are they? How is entry guarded on off hours?

These questions, says Ramos, are a matter of life and demise as a result of having sufficient licensed lifeguards on obligation is crucial to conserving youngsters protected. It may be a posh factor to determine if a pool is protected to your youngster. It will depend on the scale and depth of the pool in addition to the talent degree of all the different swimmers, based on the American Crimson Cross.

One good rule of thumb is to guarantee that every lifeguard can clearly see all components of their “zone” – the realm for which they’re accountable. A second rule is to guarantee that there are sufficient lifeguards for the variety of swimmers. Some states have set their very own particular limits. Each New York and Massachusetts, for instance, require one lifeguard per 25 swimmers at a day camp.

Since his son’s demise, Brown has been lobbying the state of North Carolina to require that every one camps require sufficient lifeguards on obligation always.

“Except the camp’s water coverage is ironclad with sufficient licensed lifeguards on obligation to soundly watch the water, don’t go away your youngster,” he says.

He needs he hadn’t left his son at day camp on that tragic day. He needs there had been enough supervision on the camp pool. He needs he had requested extra questions on it.

He needs he may return in time. However he can’t.

That’s why he chooses to inform his painful story. He doesn’t need different mother and father to have the identical regrets. And he by no means desires anybody to need to undergo the ache he has needed to bear.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here