‘Uncultured’: The Intergenerational Trauma of Girls Growing up in Cults


Content material warning: This story accommodates graphic descriptions of rape and sexual assault.

Daniella Mestyanek Younger’s powerfully immersive and exceptionally sincere debut memoir Uncultured opens with a scene of Younger standing in line to get spanked by Uncle Zephaniah. This man is just not her blood uncle, however what the children within the Kids of God cult name the boys in the neighborhood. The ladies are known as “Aunties.”

Younger is 5 years previous, the youngest of twenty-two commune children in a neighborhood of 100. The children are organized from oldest to youngest, and Younger stands on the finish of the road, anticipating her flip. 

Instantly Younger spots her mom, Kristie, and speeds over to her, immediately relieved. Her mom, with no heat in her eyes, barks, “Get again in line.”

At this second and in related moments, Younger’s mom isn’t her mother however an “auntie,” somebody in command of all the youngsters; identical to her stepfather Uncle Zephaniah is a punishment uncle, not a stepfather. As a result of Younger runs over to her mom, she’s punished with 9 swats as a substitute of three. After she tugs her underwear again up, she’s compelled to hug and thank Uncle Zephaniah for the self-discipline, as she and all the opposite children have been skilled to do.

My visceral response to this scene jolted me. Why did I really feel such rage in direction of Younger’s mom? 

As a result of this scene returned me to my very own previous.

Like Younger, I grew up in a cult, however mine was Sufi. Identical to Younger, the women and men on this neighborhood have been thought-about “household.” The ladies known as the ladies “Mama” adopted by their first identify, so Mama Yasira or Mama Batul. We known as the boys “Uncle,” or by their honorific titles equivalent to “Hajj” or “Brigadier.”

However my scenario is considerably completely different. Once I was 5 years previous, my mom and father separated after he joined the Sufi neighborhood. My mom, the daughter of Holocaust survivors, refused to vary her faith and uproot her life. After they separated, I spent 4 months of yearly with my dad in Texas, the place he’d moved with the neighborhood. I spent the remainder of the 12 months with my mom in Tucson, Ariz.

So, not like Younger, I didn’t have my organic mom within the commune, however I did have a stepmother. My dad remarried once I was 6.

After Younger was born, she was delivered to the commune nursery. This was a standard follow the place kids have been raised and cared for by “aunties.” Younger’s mom visits for nursing time until one of many different aunties nurses her—one other frequent prevalence. After her mom turns into too busy along with her workload, she solely visits Younger an hour a day, returning her to the dorms for nighttime, the place she sleeps with the opposite kids.

Once more, I used to be livid studying this as a result of, in our commune, the youngsters additionally lived individually from their dad and mom. I lived in a room with my 4 step-siblings, a courtyard away from my dad and stepmom. When unhealthy issues occurred to us, they by no means knew. I all the time felt so lonely and deserted.

In my commune, the ladies by no means had a break or time alone with their dad and mom. Day-after-day was Groundhog Day, extra of the identical. Seven days per week, I labored by cooking, cleansing and watching kids.

Younger had an exception on Sunday—”Mum or dad Day”—a wonderful day the place Younger spent the complete day along with her mom. Younger writes, “I liked Mother fiercely, although I actually didn’t know her. … She was essentially the most stunning girl on the planet.” 

On Sundays, Younger’s mom converts from Auntie Kristie to Mother. In a young scene, we see Younger’s mom instructing her to learn at 3 years previous. Younger whispers, “What’s studying for?” And her mom replies, “It’s for concepts. It’s how we study issues. … As soon as I realized to learn, I might educate myself issues.”

I lived in a room with my 4 step-siblings, a courtyard away from my dad and stepmom. When unhealthy issues occurred to us, they by no means knew.

For me, this scene was a turning level within the memoir as a result of I noticed Younger’s mom caring for her. Finally, Kristie saved her daughter by instructing her to learn, which turned Younger’s escape from the Kids of God. 

However the complexity of Younger’s mom doesn’t finish right here. Because the memoir continues, we expertise extra mind-boggling scenes. In essentially the most horrific of all, we’re in a room with Younger as an Uncle beats her. After he finishes, he rapes her, beats her once more and makes her thank him for the beating. He leaves her alone for the evening in a room with no rest room, so little lady Younger has no selection however to pee the mattress, an completely humiliating act.

Younger’s mom is my age, born in 1972, so we grew up in our cults throughout the identical durations, the 70s and 80s. Younger’s mom grew up within the Kids of God in the course of the worst years for kids, when David Berg actively inspired intercourse with minors. Fortuitously, throughout Younger’s childhood, intercourse with kids was banned. We additionally study that Younger’s mom had her when she was solely 14 after being raped by an uncle. This info was devastating and made my coronary heart break. I needed to scoop Kristie up and save her from this horrible man and all the horrible males. 

In my cult, I used to be put in a brief marriage, known as a mut’ah, once I was 12. 

I do know firsthand what occurs when a woman is raped at such a younger age—how her thoughts is messed with and her identification is corrupted. I stayed married to my husband till I used to be 20 and eventually escaped him and the cult. Fortuitously, I didn’t have any kids, however by the point Younger’s mom was 30, she had seven children. She had little to no sovereignty.

Younger by no means met her organic father. So as a substitute of directing my rage at Younger’s mom, who was powerless in an intricate system of management, I blame David Berg. I blame all of the higher-ranking males that created and enforced the foundations. I blame Younger’s father, who is sort of absent within the memoir as a result of he was lacking from his organic daughter’s life.

In my scenario, whereas I unequivocally blame the leaders and the boys who married underage women, I additionally place duty on the ladies. The ladies in my neighborhood have been not like Younger’s mom, who was introduced up within the cult and knew little else. They actively joined the cult as adults after dwelling “regular” lives. They skilled childhood freedom outdoors cult partitions, the place that they had the straightforward pleasures of studying, watching TV and attending college. Their brains have been absolutely shaped earlier than they joined the cult. Nothing can excuse their abuse of the youngsters.

However like Younger, the buck stops with me. 

Like Younger, training saved me. I used to be in a position to transcend my circumstances via crucial considering.

I’ve two grown sons from my second marriage, 25 and 26. I helicopter-parented in some ways, conserving them tremendous shut, turning into the precise reverse of the mamas who uncared for and deserted their kids.

At this time, my father and stepmother nonetheless actively take part in the neighborhood, although by now, group members have scattered, and the bodily web site not exists. We’ll in all probability by no means share the identical views, however that’s okay. We’re all born with completely different life paths.

After escaping, I went on to get a Ph.D. in social sciences. Like Younger, training saved me. I used to be in a position to transcend my circumstances via crucial considering. At this time, I stand in my energy as a result of I can step again. I analyze my scenario, painfully settle for the horrible issues that occurred and know with certainty that I’m by no means going again.

The intergenerational trauma of cult life ends with my technology—proper right here and now. 

U.S. democracy is at a harmful inflection level—from the demise of abortion rights, to a scarcity of pay fairness and parental go away, to skyrocketing maternal mortality, and assaults on trans well being. Left unchecked, these crises will result in wider gaps in political participation and illustration. For 50 years, Ms. has been forging feminist journalism—reporting, rebelling and truth-telling from the front-lines, championing the Equal Rights Modification, and centering the tales of these most impacted. With all that’s at stake for equality, we’re redoubling our dedication for the subsequent 50 years. In flip, we’d like your assist, Support Ms. today with a donation—any amount that is meaningful to you. For as little as $5 each month, you’ll obtain the print journal together with our e-newsletters, motion alerts, and invites to Ms. Studios occasions and podcasts. We’re grateful in your loyalty and ferocity.

Up subsequent:


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here