White Men Are the Last Best Hope for Herschel Walker in Georgia Senate Runoff


Sen. Raphael Warnock (D-Ga.) at a marketing campaign rally that includes former President Barack Obama on Dec. 1, 2022 in Atlanta. Warnock continues to marketing campaign all through Georgia for the runoff election on Dec. 6 in opposition to his Republican challenger Herschel Walker. (Win McNamee / Getty Photographs)

What occurs in Georgia Dec. 6 doesn’t keep in Georgia. If Democratic U.S. Senator Raphael Warnock can maintain off Republican challenger Herschel Walker and win reelection, the Democrats will acquire a 51-49 benefit within the Senate, giving them slim however clear majorities in key committees. Vice President Kamala Harris will not have to forged tie-breaking votes to go laws, affirm federal judges, and in any other case advance liberal and progressive priorities.

Regardless of Walker’s broadly reported manifest deficits as a candidate, together with a long record of misogynous abuse and coercive conduct towards girls, and blatant hypocrisy on the problem of abortion, the race continues to be too near name.

Many pundits have scratched their heads and puzzled how a race between two African American males, one a considerate and revered Christian minister who occupies the identical pulpit as Martin Luther King, Jr., and the opposite a personable however deeply flawed former soccer star, is even shut. However their evaluation usually lacks greater than a superficial understanding of the intersecting gender, racial and social gathering politics at play.

A lot of the hope for a Democratic victory hinges on the opportunity of an enormous turnout amongst voters of colour, and younger voters. Since record-breaking numbers have already voted, which most observers say advantages the Democrats, it seems as if this groundswell is already underway. 

A lot of the hope for a Republican victory rests equally on massive turnout. However within the case of the GOP, the turnout they want is of white voters, particularly white males, who’re by far the social gathering’s most necessary constituency in Georgia and each different state. 

The GOP has made beneficial properties in latest cycles amongst voters of colour, particularly males. Based on NBC News exit polls from the Nov. 8 election, whereas solely 5 % of Black girls voted for Walker, 12 % of Black males did. There was the same gender hole amongst Latino voters. 

White girls additionally supported Walker by a large margin that was much more pronounced alongside class strains. Fifty-four % of white college-educated girls went for Walker—a quantity that was 25 proportion factors decrease than girls with no faculty (79), who, notably, supported the alleged abuser of ladies at charges much like their male counterparts.

However Walker completely trounced Warnock amongst white males by 71-27 %. This was almost equivalent to the margin that Donald Trump had over Joe Biden amongst these Georgia voters within the 2020 presidential race. Walker’s benefit amongst white males with out a faculty diploma was an astounding 80-19 %.

But regardless of these dramatic numbers, few mainstream political analysts have even talked about—a lot much less thoughtfully mentioned—the white male vote in Georgia, and what it says in regards to the present state of our politics because the GOP prepares to take again slim management of the Home of Representatives.     

Walker’s benefit amongst white males with out a faculty diploma was an astounding 80-19 %. But regardless of these dramatic numbers, few mainstream political analysts have even talked about—a lot much less thoughtfully mentioned.

This lack of consideration is fully comprehensible from the attitude of Democratic political operatives on the bottom in Georgia, as essentially the most life like technique for profitable elections like this one is to inspire your base and get them to the polls. As soon as elections are underway, it makes little sense to expend valuable marketing campaign assets on making an attempt to steer white males to vote Democratic. That’s longer-term work. Alas, the very purpose why Democratic victories so usually require a large turnout amongst folks of colour, younger folks, and single girls is in an effort to counteract the voting energy of these exact same white males.

This Senate runoff election is in some methods a microcosm of the electoral challenges nationwide Democrats face in coming years, and the tensions concerned in cobbling collectively electoral majorities in a rustic during which 74 million folks voted for Donald Trump in 2020, regardless of dwelling by 4 years of his chaotic and deeply divisive presidency and his disastrous mismanagement of the coronavirus pandemic, to not point out the Large Lie he has unfold because the election.  

Racism is a part of the rationale why a major chunk of the white working-class abandoned the Democratic Get together.

One of many central conundrums the social gathering faces is the way to attraction to what Stacey Abrams calls the “New American Majority” whereas concurrently profitable again the assist of not less than a viable phase of white working-class voters, a lot of whom abandoned the Democratic Get together many years in the past—within the South and elsewhere—however who nonetheless comprise essential percentages of the voters in voting districts nationwide.

This stress within the Democratic coalition has persevered in a single type or one other because the early ’70s, when the aftermath of the civil rights motion, antagonisms sparked by the Vietnam Struggle, and the rise of the ladies’s and LGBTQ actions, in live performance with elevated company assaults on organized labor, opened fissures within the Democratic social gathering that stay to today.

With the doable exception of the preternaturally charismatic Barack Obama’s election and re-election in 2008/2012, and Joe Biden’s win in a pandemic-ravaged nation in 2020, the social gathering has not been in a position to efficiently sew collectively a secure electoral majority ever since. That is in massive as a result of they’ve misplaced the assist of so many white working-class voters all around the nation—not solely within the South. Racism is a part of the rationale why a major chunk of the white working-class abandoned the Democratic Get together.

However there are numerous different causes, together with the notion by many working-class whites that in latest many years the historic social gathering of the blue-collar employee forgot about them in its rush to serve the pursuits of an unlikely alliance of world capital, college-educated professionals, feminist girls and “metrosexual” males, racial minorities, and ethnic immigrants.

This notion is fed day by day on Fox Information and right-wing speak radio, the place hosts and company declare repeatedly that Democrats and liberals “hate white males,” and mock the manhood of any man who helps liberal and progressive insurance policies.

In his shock victory over Hillary Clinton in 2016, Donald Trump efficiently satisfied tens of millions of working-class and decrease middle-class whites—particularly however not completely males—that in contrast to the Democratic coastal elites who supposedly look down on working folks, he actually cared about their plight and would tirelessly battle for them.

In fact, as soon as elected, Trump ruled—in substance if not type—like a standard conservative Republican, passing an enormous tax reduce that benefitted the rich, making an attempt to roll again beneficial properties on entry to well being take care of tens of millions of People, gutting rules that profit staff and shoppers, and appointing corporatist judges to the federal bench, together with the Supreme Court docket, that rule overwhelmingly in opposition to the rights of staff and “the widespread man and lady” when their rights come into battle with company income. 

However conservative media hardly ever permits any airtime for these types of inconvenient information, or something which may complicate the narrative that “actual males” ought to vote Republican. Day-after-day within the right-wing universe of political angertainment, (white) males hear the dual messages of impending apocalypse (our civilization is below existential menace) and inspirational calls to them as its saviors (we’d like you to put it aside).

A farewell speech in Congress delivered lately by far-right North Carolina Republican Consultant Madison Cawthorne, who misplaced his reelection bid in a major, sums up the gendered attraction of the MAGA proper:  

“Our younger males are taught that weak point is power, that delicacy is fascinating, and that being a comfortable metrosexual is extra beneficial than coaching the thoughts, physique, and soul. Social media has weakened us, siphoning our males of their will to battle, to rise in a noble method, sq. their jaws and cost as soon as extra into the breach of life and defend what they love.

“So on this precipice of catastrophe I ask the younger males of this nation a query: Will you sit behind a display screen whereas the story tales of your forefathers develop into delusion? Or will you stand resolute in opposition to the dying mild of America’s Golden Age? Will you reclaim your masculinity? Will you develop into a person to be feared, to be revered, to be appeared as much as? Or will you let this nation’s subsequent era be its ultimate era?”

Republican U.S. Senate candidate Herschel Walker at a marketing campaign rally on Nov. 7, 2022 in Kennesaw, Ga. (Alex Wong / Getty Photographs)

This conservative attraction to “masculinity” helps to clarify why—regardless of Walker’s quite a few gaffes and weird statements on the marketing campaign path—he has saved this election inside the margin of error. It has merely develop into unthinkable for tens of millions of white males to vote for a celebration they see—in crudely stereotypical and misogynous phrases—as comfortable, weak and effeminate. 

The gender politics of this contest are even starker as a result of Walker’s hero standing as a soccer star in “Dawg Nation,” the place soccer is king. Stephen Lawson, who organized a political committee for Walker, had this clarification. 

“The actual fact of the matter is,” he stated, “there are 40-, 50-year-old males throughout the state who sleep of their No. 34 jerseys at night time. He’s an icon. He’s a hero on this state, and the despicable assaults that come in opposition to him will one hundred pc backfire.”

Walker himself often references his sports activities previous as a optimistic rationale for his candidacy. “God ready me for this second as a result of he didn’t desire a politician. I’m not a politician. I can run that soccer.  I can run observe. And I do all these different issues. I’m that warrior that God was in search of.”

There will likely be many to issues to look at for within the Georgia runoff. Certainly one of them will likely be what number of white males prove to vote for a disastrously unqualified candidate merely as a result of he has an “R” subsequent to his identify and the “blue-collar billionaire” endorsed him. And if regardless of all his baggage an awesome variety of white males nonetheless vote for Herschel Walker, what’s going to it soak up future elections for them to assist candidates who not solely don’t abuse girls however as a substitute deal with them with respect—personally and politically—and who champion insurance policies that really assist working folks and their households?

Up subsequent:

U.S. democracy is at a harmful inflection level—from the demise of abortion rights, to a scarcity of pay fairness and parental go away, to skyrocketing maternal mortality, and assaults on trans well being. Left unchecked, these crises will result in wider gaps in political participation and illustration. For 50 years, Ms. has been forging feminist journalism—reporting, rebelling and truth-telling from the front-lines, championing the Equal Rights Modification, and centering the tales of these most impacted. With all that’s at stake for equality, we’re redoubling our dedication for the following 50 years. In flip, we’d like your assist, Support Ms. today with a donation—any amount that is meaningful to you. For as little as $5 each month, you’ll obtain the print journal together with our e-newsletters, motion alerts, and invites to Ms. Studios occasions and podcasts. We’re grateful to your loyalty and ferocity.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here